Under the Rainbow

November 2017

Must everything be politicized these days? Even football has fallen for the trend. You can’t watch an NFL game these days without witnessing players kneeling or sitting during the national anthem, in protest of — what? Police brutality? Racial inequality? A foul-mouthed President? It’s not even clear anymore.

In San Diego, a town professional football recently abandoned, the Mass itself has become politicized — at least at one Catholic parish. On October 7, St. John the Evangelist celebrated a “Mass for families of the LGBT community.” In times like these, when the most intense skirmish in the culture wars involves the legitimization of the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgendered “lifestyles,” and when the Church is seen as the last holdout to surrender, it is difficult to imagine a more politically charged point of emphasis to lend to a Catholic liturgy.

We wish we could tell you that St. John the Evangelist is a Catholic community gone rogue. But no. The parish hosted its LGBT Mass with the full consent and cooperation of the Diocese of San Diego. In fact, Auxiliary Bishop John Dolan made a personal appearance, concelebrating the LGBT Mass. And Bishop Robert McElroy had previously praised the parish — in San Diego’s newspaper of record, no less — precisely for being a place that makes LGBT people “feel particularly welcome,” which, he said, “is a very good thing” (Union-Tribune, Oct. 29, 2016).

Sending a high mucky-muck from the home office was a self-consciously symbolic gesture. It meant to convey that “the church as an institution is with the people, with all people,” Laura Spencer-Martin, director of the diocese’s Office for Family Life and Spirituality, told San Diego LGBT Weekly (Sept. 14). Yes, diocesan personnel now grant puffs to the gay press.


You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.



New Oxford Notes: November 2017

Read our posting policy Add a comment
While it is vital and essential to love people with sexual development issues which are so often an effect of abuse on many levels, we do not do anyone any good by ignoring the most obvious fact of human identity, the complementary nature of being male and female. We are only intelligible naturally in relation to the complementary sex. That said, I hope we catholics are known and experienced as sinners who love and welcome other sinners to the table of the Lord of mercy and forgiveness. A difficult road to walk at times but simply ignoring our actual human nature is not a solution. Posted by: Paul Boire1
November 07, 2017 09:38 AM EST
Add a comment


©