New York Times reporter Josh Barro ditched the traditional concept of the impersonal reporter and let his visceral bias bleed across cyberspace this summer. On July 23 he tweeted, Anti-LGBT attitudes are terrible for people in all sorts of communities. They linger and oppress, and we need to stamp them out, ruthlessly. Reporters arent supposed to interject their personal bias into news coverage. Nor should they be making public commentaries on social issues in any venue, at least if they want to be taken seriously as journalists. But Barros out-of-the-blue tweet is no mere lapse in professional judgment. Its a confirmation of what many Americans have long suspected: The nations elite media-makers are no mere reporters of the news.
The attitudes of journalists like Barro are shaping the mindset of the American public, especially regarding same-sex marriage, the political hot-button issue of this decade. Truth be told, theres no real surprise here, especially among NOR readers. What is surprising is that Barro would have the temerity to bandy about this kind of brazen intolerance. When one proclaims that certain attitudes or views ought to be ruthlessly stamped out, thats a succinct way of saying theres no room for dialogue, debate, or dissent. In fact, critics could not be blamed for interpreting Barros proclamation as a kind of call to action possibly a violent one.
To be fair, Barro later clarified that he isnt calling for anyones death, just that we should make anti-LGBT views shameful like segregation. Not saying we should off people.
But who could be blamed for thinking that Barro is a wee bit fanatical and not a little illogical and inconsistent? Someone needs to get this memo to the Times journalist: No one uses the word ruthlessly with stamp out unless he is advocating the use of excessive force without regard for mercy or tolerance. The idea that intolerance will not be tolerated is so oxymoronic as to make the mind spin.
You have two options:
- Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
- Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.
If you're already a subscriber log-in here.