Shriveled Is Good

May 2003

A full-page ad in America magazine (Feb. 17, 2003) caught our eye. One reason it stood out was its striking resemblance to our own hallmark ads. The ad has a black-and-white drawing with lots of text, and a snappy headline in large boldface type. The headline of this ad is "Small is Good."

The ad is for the American College of Louvain (ACL) seminary in the Flemish part of Belgium, run by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops and the oldest national seminary for Americans, founded in 1857. The ad states: "When it comes to business, bigger is usually better. When it comes to Church, does the same principle apply? Many lay-people, parish priests and bishops know otherwise. Often enough, their most vibrant parishes are their small parishes...the ones where everyone knows everyone, where a familial spirit presides, where the sacramental communion celebrated every Sunday supports a real communion among the parishioners" (ellipses and italics in original). Read that last clause again, and you'll see that it's being asserted in a round about way that sacramental Communion is not real. Recall, please, our New Oxford Note "Hocus-Pocus Catholicism?" (Feb.), where we noted how the Rector of ACL, Fr. Kevin Codd, suggested that the Lord is present in sacramental Communion in a "natural" way, not a supernatural way, thereby denying the reality of Transubstantiation.

The ACL ad continues: "For almost ten years, our seminary has been a small one...and frankly we like it this way" (ellipses in original). Really now? Ten years earlier your seminary was larger. Now it's small. This is progress? This ad reeks of being a projection of ACL's insecurity about its size and potency.

So just how small is ACL? The ad doesn't say. Why not? Why leave it to the reader's imagination? Well then, how big would a big seminary be? Big seminaries in the U.S. have around 300 to 400 seminarians.

Then a "small" seminary would have how many students? Most savvy people would probably agree that any seminary with about 50 students would be small.


You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.



New Oxford Notes: May 2003

Read our posting policy Add a comment
Try our semminary in El Paso, Texas. We have 4 semminarians for a Catholic population of over four hundred thousand, oh and 87 or so priests, many of them aging. Posted by: ragcia149
May 30, 2006 05:58 PM EDT
The ACL sounds moribund to me. Also, from "Fr." Cobb's remark, it sounds as though the ACL is as heretical as the Chicago Theological Union. Posted by: mccaw
July 02, 2007 12:47 AM EDT
Add a comment


©