What Lies Beneath

December 2010

Crises have a way of bringing people together. The case of the Chilean miners who were trapped 2,300 feet underground for over two months provided further proof of this principle. Their successful mid-October rescue was a feat not only of human ingenuity but also of what many believe to be divine intervention. The spiritual overtones of the interment and rescue were unmistakable — even jaded secularist mediots couldn’t help but notice.

It seemed as though the whole world was tuned in to the dramatic events taking place at the San José mine. Television crews from as far away as Russia, Japan, Iran, and North Korea came to Copiapó to capture the moment for home audiences eager for good news about the buried miners’ fate — yes, even members of the so-called Axis of Evil were on hand. The entire ordeal was colored by the intense faith of the miners, their families, and their rescuers; it was indeed a triumph of hope, one of the foremost theological virtues. Not coincidentally, the makeshift camp set up for the miners’ families was dubbed Camp Hope, and one of the miners’ wives who gave birth while her husband was trapped underground named their new daughter Esperanza, Spanish for Hope.

It was a jubilant moment when the last of the thirty-three miners reached the surface. Chilean President Sebastian Piñera was present and addressed him: “The country is not the same after this. You were an inspiration.” Not to be outdone, U.S. President Barack Obama said the rescue “inspired the world.” The resultant euphoria reinvigorated, however temporarily, a sense of the common bond of humanity and, among believers, led to a renewed sense of our common faith in the providence of God.

Or so it seemed.

While Catholic News Service trumpeted the occasion with the headline “As Miners Are Rescued, Chileans Unite in Prayer” (Oct. 14), beneath the pomp of camaraderie, togetherness, and a general sense of good will, a different, more sobering picture began to emerge, one that brought into bold relief the deep divisions that have rent Christendom for the past half-millennium. London’s Guardian ran an article with the headline “Chilean Miners: Rival Churches Claim Credit for the Miracle” (Oct. 11). Evangelicals, Adventists, and Catholics, the Guardian reported, “are vying to stamp their own particular faith” on the “surge in religious fervor” that accompanied the miners’ rescue.

You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.

New Oxford Notes: December 2010

Read our posting policy Add a comment
Why be so concerned with "playing nice" with those who are trying to steal souls? To find out what True Ecumenism is, please consult the beautiful Pope Pius XI Encyclical, "Mortalium Animos" ("On Religious Unity"). It seems that the Catholic clergy and hierarchy in Chile were doing exactly what they should do, and did it without seeking fanfare - and the same can be said for Pope Benedict. So, why give any credence to heretical beliefs by hosting an 'ecumenical' liturgy. According to authentic Catholic teaching, ecumenism consists in inviting all souls to enter into the fullness if the faith - the Church. Posted by: mjtridentine
December 24, 2010 04:00 PM EST
Add a comment