'I Learned That I Need to Keep My Mouth Shut'

December 2003

The Palm Beach Post (Oct. 11) reports that Fr. John J. Pasquini was relieved of his duties after only three months at St. Juliana Church in West Palm Beach, Florida, and was sent packing to a hospital chaplaincy. Chaplaincies at hospitals are "dumping grounds for clerics," notes The Post (if you don't believe that, just recall for a moment what happened to Fr. Cornelius Buckley, S.J., and Fr. Joseph Fessio, S.J.).

So, what did Fr. Pasquini do that was so terrible? Well, The Post begins its story this way: "An outspoken Catholic priest who publicly condemned homosexuality and criticized Episcopalians for electing a gay bishop is being removed from his church and transferred to a job as a hospital chaplain."

Would the Diocese of Palm Beach admit to that? According to the story, the Vicar General of the Diocese, Fr. Charles Notabartolo, claims that the reason for the removal was because Fr. Pasquini's "homilies were poor" and "he didn't show enough devotion to Mass." On the other hand, Fr. Pasquini (who graduated top in his class at seminary, has two master's degrees, and has written 12 books) says that no one complained to him about his homilies or his devotion to Mass.

The Post says: "Pasquini caused a firestorm of controversy and irked the head of the Anglican diocese when he sent a letter to The Palm Beach Post, published Aug. 15. In response to an earlier column endorsing gay marriages, Pasquini wrote that homosexuality is contrary to God's law, quoted scripture to support his point and concluded with this aside: ‘Also, about the recent election of a gay bishop, Episcopalianism and its counterpart, Anglicanism, have been on the decline for centuries, and the more this religion compromises with a pagan culture, the more it will continue to decline.' Last year, as head of the diocesan Right to Life office, Pasquini wrote an editorial in The Florida Catholic that complained about a subculture of gay priests and accused the church of cronyism, and favoritism."

Judging by appearances, it looks like the Lavender Mafia got its revenge.


You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.



New Oxford Notes: December 2003

Read our posting policy Add a comment
Nice article. Another brave priest is sent to the gulag. The bishops remain more afraid of controversy than they are of evil. If they used that "bad homilies" criteria here in San Antonio, 95% of pastors would be hospital chaplains.

WK... oops, I meant KS

Posted by: simcic
August 29, 2007 11:44 PM EDT
True ecumenism exists between the Episcopal and Roman Catholic lavendars. Oh my. Posted by: martillo
August 30, 2007 11:09 AM EDT
The priest should not KEEP HIS MOUTH SHUT. No - he should shout out the truth to all the corners of his diocese. He should - he must - stand up to and oppose his Bishop if he has to. The Canon does not indicate blind obedience by a priest to an errant bishop. The fact of the matter is that we must all become more militant catholics. We must all challenge the heretics in our parishes and amongst our clergy and take them to task for their buffoonery. hey, I do it all the time here in the archdiocese of NY. I've taken the Cardinal to task, his director of CCD, sister Jane Curtin (a skirt of a nun, mind you), the vicar of Sullivan County, and several others, over scandalous happenings which are being allowed. Was I paid any mind? Not really until I made some of the problems public on the internet. Then I began getting calls and letters to desist. I DID NOT. I am still fighting. Not for my glorification, but so that the offenses against Our Lord will stop. JOIN ME!!! Posted by: gespin3549
August 30, 2007 05:50 PM EDT
Add a comment