DONATE TODAY!: Join the NOR Associates
When you express too much, you run the risk of being misunderstood, Pope Francis admitted in his lengthy interview with Fr. Antonio Spadaro, S.J., published this September in Jesuit magazines across the world. So, has the Holy Father been misunderstood? Its been amusing to watch impassioned commentators try to explain away the Popes interview, putting their rosiest spin on his words: The media took the Pope out of context or He just wants a more pastoral Church. But a hard question must be asked: Why is it that gay-rights advocates and abortion promoters are lauding Pope Francis for his words, while many faithful Catholics are perplexed and apprehensive?
Conservative Catholic commentators have gone out of their way to assure us that the Holy Father hasnt contradicted Church teaching or changed Church doctrine. That much is true. When popes give interviews they typically say nothing new that is, if were talking about defining Church doctrine on matters of faith and morals. Interviews, nevertheless, can cause a host of problems (recall Pope Benedict XVIs famous condoms comment; see our New Oxford Note Condom-mania, the Rerun, Jan.-Feb. 2011), especially when the Church is not prepared for the fallout. This time around, although secular media outlets received advance copies of the text under embargo, bishops and their spokesmen did not.
Archbishop Charles Chaput of Philadelphia, for example, said that it was a blessing to have been away from the United States on September 19 when Jesuit magazines around the world released the Popes remarks. He returned home to a deluge of e-mails. Some people grasped at the interview like a lifeline or a vindication, he wrote in Catholic Philadelphia (Sept. 25). One person praised the Holy Father for stressing that the Church must focus on compassion and mercy, not on enforcing small-minded rules. She added that were at last free from the chains of hatred that have ruled the Catholic Church for so many years and led to my unease in bringing my own children into that Church. But most of the e-mails the archbishop received were from catechists, priests, and laymen who felt confused or disillusioned by the interview: A priest said the Pope has implicitly accused brother priests who are serious about moral issues of being small minded, and that [if youre a priest,] being morally serious is now likely to get you publicly cast as a problem. Another priest wrote that the problem is that [the Holy Father] makes all of the wrong people happy, people who will never believe in the Gospel and who will continue to persecute the Church.
Consider that the National Abortion Rights Action League (NARAL) jumped on the effusive-praise bandwagon and posted a Thank you to Francis from Pro-choice women everywhere on Facebook, while the Human Rights Campaign, a lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender advocacy group, tweeted an image with the words, Dear Pope Francis, thank you. LGBT people everywhere.
You have two options:
- Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
- Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.
If you're already a subscriber log-in here.