The Catholic Church has recently given an inch by asking for forgiveness for the sins of her members. Not satisfied, Commonweal seems to want to grab the whole nine yards. Introducing a symposium, Commonweal (Nov. 19, 1999) asks respondents if the Church can confess doctrinal errors, not merely sins.
We all know that doctrine can develop, but no apology is needed to do that because when that happens truth is generating greater truth, and no error was involved. But Commonweal is interested in doctrinal errors, and therefore in apologies. Thus Commonweal expresses doubts about the concept of the development of doctrine: Its a legalistic maneuver that may involve tortuous reasoning; it breeds cynicism and is perhaps hypocritical.
The concept of development, says Commonweal, also produces frustration. It appears that Commonweal itself is frustrated. Why? Because Commonweal seems to sense that the concept of development cant possibly yield the results liberal Catholics want in the two current neuralgic issues Commonweal cites: contraception and the ordination of women.
Look: Contraception is, according to the Catechism, intrinsically evil i.e., always wrong. Its quite a stretch to imagine that this doctrine could be developed to say the opposite. Also, that women cannot be priests is infallible teaching. How could this doctrine be developed to say the opposite? So Commonweal seems to have a problem! Thus Commonweal asks (with its own tortuous rhetoric), why not just admit that such doctrines are erroneous and simply change or reverse them?
You have two options:
- Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
- Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.
If you're already a subscriber log-in here.