Contending for the Faith
November 1996By Dale Vree
As expected, our October editorial (The Shot Heard Round the World), which supported Bishop Fabian Bruskewitzs excommunication of Catholics in his diocese who belong to 12 specified anti-Church organizations, generated lots of letters. The vast majority of letters have been favorable, and some appear in this issues letters section.
One letter-writer, Manuel Perez in El Paso, Texas, congratulated us on the editorial, and asked how the U.S. bishops have reacted to Bruskewitzs action. And so, wed like to oblige Mr. Perez here.
Overall, the reaction has been varied. Some in the hierarchy, such as Bishop Myers of Peoria and Cardinal Law of Boston, have offered supportive comments. The primary target of Bruskewitzs action is Call to Action (CTA), which favors the usual laundry list of trendy dissenting causes, and we are aware of four bishops who, not unlike Bruskewitz, have taken concrete actions against CTA in their dioceses (DArcy of Fort Wayne-South Bend, Curtiss of Omaha, Cronin of Hartford, and Keating of Arlington).
On the other hand, while many bishops have kept their opinions to themselves, others have taken a stance like that of Chicagos now-deceased Cardinal Bernardin, who, a week after Bruskewitzs action, responded to it by saying, my approach has been to pursue dialogue with CTA. Of course, the basic strategy of CTA, which is headquartered in Chicago, is to engage the hierarchy in dialogue. Moreover, less than five months after Bruskewitzs action, Bernardin launched the Catholic Common Ground Project (discussed in our Nov. editorial, Rome Under Siege), and the point of that Project is, going by its original statement of purpose, to foster dialogue between Catholic teaching and dissent. Indeed, Bernardin stated that one reason he launched the Project when he did was because he was so troubled with Bruskewitzs action. And to no ones surprise, CTA announced its support of Bernardins Project.
You have two options:
- Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
- Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.
If you're already a subscriber log-in here.