THE AMISH VS. THE DEPOPULATION BOMB
The Technological Society: Where What's Artificial Seems Natural

October 1994By Eric Brende

Eric Brende farms in southern Kentucky. He has worked as an Amish farm hand, and has studied Amish culture as a graduate student at M.I.T., where he is presently a doctoral candidate (on leave). He is also a Contributing Editor of Caelum et Terra.

My family and I had just left my sister-in-law's place in Norwich, Connecticut, and I found myself perusing a tourist magazine titled Discover Connecticut. What absorbed me most, as I thumbed backwards through the articles on historic tours, restored downtown areas, and forest preserves, were the photographs of magnificent real estate for sale in the Connecticut countryside at prices I knew I could never afford. And then I got to the "editorial page." The title, a bit incongruously, said something about "sex education." Paragraph after paragraph of blithe advocacy it was, exalting the need for new and expanded information, the more explicit and thoroughgoing the better, enlightening all grammar school children down to kindergarten on the neces­sity of, and deft use of paraphernalia for, sterile sexual intercourse.

The author, a short biography related, is a regis­tered nurse; never once during her piece did she betray the awareness that anyone might possibly have the tiniest reservation about her recommendations. Question Progress? The feeling I got, indeed, was re­markably similar to the impression I receive when scanning our society's approach to technology in general, the imperative underlying the seemingly unstoppable technical progression of the last 200 years: "Anything that can be done, will be done." An­other way to put this is that improved artificial means of contraception, like television, automobiles, and computers, are seen as entitlements -- not as sub­stances rife with potential danger, but as naturally and rightfully ours, and as limitlessly usable and un­questionably salutary as the air we breathe, and that whatever side effects they may bring can be managed by further applications of technology or technique. Jocelyn Elders, President Clinton's Surgeon General, summed the sentiment up quite bluntly: "We've taught our children in driver's education what to do in the front seat, and now we've got to teach them what to do in the back seat." It is interesting to note the automobile's role as precursor in this seemingly inexorable development.

Soon we arrived back home from our trip (ad­mittedly by automobile) to our small farm, in proximity to a thriving Old Order Amish community, whose households, bustling with eight or more chil­dren per family, flout the American status quo. The ban on contraceptives is one of many Amish technological restrictions -- e.g., on cars, electricity, and, in this particular enclave, all motors. (The term "Amish" here encompasses both Old Order Amish and Old Or­der Mennonite groups, which share many similar re­strictions regarding technology.)

Is it a coincidence that Elders linked the car with the condom? Or that in Amish society a ban on one goes along with a ban on the other? Artificial contra­ception is often seen as a cause (of sexual promiscu­ity, weakening of the marital bond, and a host of de­rived sociological problems), less often as an effect. Those who would focus all attention on the Pill or the condom risk treating the symptoms and not the deeper disease. Unfortunately, Catholic social teach­ing seems to address the contraception problem in isolation and not link it to antecedent technical and social developments that may have paved the way for it. The result has seemed as artificial as the Pill itself, a kind of "grit your teeth and bear it" approach, that ig­nores deeper structural factors.


You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.



Back to October 1994 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
Be the first to comment on this story!


©