Faith Journey or Road to Hell?

December 2008By Richard Anderson

Richard Anderson is a professor of critical thinking and argumentation at California State Polytechnic University, Pomona.

More and more frequently in our New Age culture we hear the phrase "faith journey." Individuals are described as on a lifelong "faith journey" to either God or "The Force" or a Big Guy in the Sky or some great beyond. It seems that supplying details concerning that "journey" is not necessary and that required actions or specific beliefs are irrelevant. Three examples demonstrate.

A couple of years ago the owner of two "gay bars," which were apparently used for pornographic filmmaking, was denied burial in the Catholic churches of San Diego, California. The rector of an Episcopalian church jumped in with self-proclaimed "love and compassion" to offer his cathedral for the bar owner's funeral services. During the ceremony he asserted that the recently deceased was on a "faith journey" and that no one should judge his actions since we all are on our way to God, and presumably Heaven.

The second example involves two young people who ignored Catholic doctrine by shacking up together for a couple of years and begetting one child before finally deciding to tie the knot. Resplendent in her white wedding gown, the bride heard the priest tell the assembled that these two (really three by now) were on their own "faith journey," and they were now on the right track. These "faith sojourners," however, never went to church before or after the ceremony, currently receive none of the sacraments, and are not raising their first or second child in the faith. These individuals are, indeed on a journey. But faith, especially the Catholic faith, has nothing to do with that journey.

The final example of where the term was used to simply excuse behavior not at all consistent with Catholic principles dealt with the untimely death of a friend of a friend of this author. The deceased had abandoned his religion some thirty years before his death, married outside of the Church, raised his children with no faith, and referred to himself as a "recovering Catholic." His orthodox Catholic parents tried to console themselves by stating that there are many ways to God, and their son's "faith journey" was roundabout. It defies imagination just how anyone with any sense of objectivity could agree with that assessment. An individual who thumbs his nose at the Catholic religion for all of his adult life can hardly be described to be on any sort of journey of faith. Comforting sentiments, yes; truthfulness in terms of reality, no.

You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.

Back to December 2008 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
Well spoken, Professor Anderson!

God, I wish you were teaching me when I was in college. And you are a tenured instructor at a state school? Wow, the age of miracles is NOT over!

As We say in my part of the great northeast, "Keep on keepin'-on, brother in the Lord!"
Posted by: Pozzi
December 15, 2008 09:13 AM EST
Wonderful! I am exhausted by all of the nonsensical labels applied to what is simply a lack of faith and devotion. Prof Anderson, pls consider doing some podcasts or downloadable mp3 files (Keep The Faith.org has many on their site and this woujld be a great addition). Would like to see more of this work and all of NOR on audio files - we have much to learn from this great publication. God bless you all! Posted by: tomoxford
December 15, 2008 09:26 AM EST
What a refreshing and wonderful message! THank you Prof. Anderson, for setting the record straight on what the Church actually teaches instead of what misguided priests teach in most of their sermons. I'm so tired of hearing watered-down Catholicism these days. And I'm afraid that so many people are being led astray because they don't read the writings of the saints and Church documents and they receive poor training from so many wishy-washy priests and lay people. Keep spreading the truth! Christo et Ecclesiae! Posted by: joeakin85
December 30, 2008 07:17 PM EST
Add a comment