GUEST COLUMN
The Blame Game

December 2005By Thomas Finneran

Sgt. Thomas Finneran is a retired policeman of 23 years' service in New York City.

Approximately 22 percent of adults in the U.S. suffer from diagnosable mental disorders. This statistic attracts a lot of converts to the new religion of psychiatry. Although most recognized religions have a set of rules and moral imperatives, such as the Ten Commandments, which one must follow, this is not the case with psychiatry, which places the blame elsewhere. Psychiatry takes away guilt and responsibility for one's actions or omissions -- how nice! -- and replaces them with something akin to "the Devil made me do it." The Devil in this case has been replaced by the words "addiction" and "compulsion," etc.

In psychiatry, chemical imbalances explain away reprehensible behavior. Failing that, it can always be attributed to your parents. Your mother is usually the culprit when the blame is assessed, either because she didn't love you enough or she smothered you with it. Either way, it's not your fault.

Psychiatry has replaced pastoral counseling in many of our churches. Bishop Fulton J. Sheen warned in the 1960s of the disintegration of religious values and social responsibility at the hands of psychiatry. A 1986 survey published by The American Journal of Psychiatry found that 95 percent of psychiatrists consider themselves atheist or agnostic. Sigmund Freud, in his book The Future of an Illusion, called religion "the universal neurosis of humanity."

Paul Pruyser, former director of the Department of Education of the Menninger Foundation, a psychiatric group in the U.S., reported on the impact of the psychiatric disciplines on the training of the clergy: "The word soul has lost its meaning and even its plausibility…. Faith, hope and love can no longer be seen simply as virtues or graces; they are processes in flesh and blood."


You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.



Back to December 2005 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
Part of what you say is true, but notice while you attend Sunday Mass our priest will never confront the evils of society and as a result many Catholics have a false sense of morality. I see this in all areas of life,just look how many Catholics support abortion,contraceptin and same sex marraige.What you see in psychiatry is a mere reflection of society in general. I work in psychiatry and one of my patients is a lesbian. However,she was terribly sexually abused by by multiple men in childhood and as a teen. She doesn't trust men. It is very difficult for me as a counselor to change her sexual habits, especially when she is not Catholic. I try to help her cope with PTSD and severe anxiety she has developed to the extent she has difficulty being in the public venue.Life has been curel to some and medication does help the patient from past issues. You seem to have a personal vendetta towards this profession, but this same "immorality" you view in psychiatry can be applied to all other venues in life. Posted by: Jerry
September 07, 2012 08:28 AM EDT
Add a comment