The Revolution in the Catholic Church: Unstoppable, Defeated, or What?
November 1999By Dale Vree
As we prepare to enter the new millennium, there are two basic views on the state of the Church.
One view holds that Vatican II was a kind of Sixties happening that is revolutionizing the Church. The revolution is ongoing and is yet to reach its fulfillment, and it will reach its fulfillment because the revolution is unstoppable.
The other view holds that Vatican II was not a revolutionary phenomenon, and that the revolutionary mood following Vatican II is coming to an end.
The first view can be seen in an article by Fr. Andrew Greeley in Commonweal (Sept. 11, 1998). Greeley identified several crucial changes that emerged from or after Vatican II: The altar was turned around, the Latin Mass was abandoned, fish on Friday was dropped, and the heretics, schismatics, Jews, and infidels down the street were now suddenly separated brothers and sisters. The changes occurred virtually overnight, showing that Catholicism was willing to change when it wanted to. The psychology set in motion was this: The immutable had mutated. What would change next? More precisely, according to Greeley, many Catholics concluded that the church can change whatever it wants, if only it wants to, and that if something ought to be changed and it would be changed eventually, then it was all right to anticipate such change on ones own authority. Thus, says Greeley, Catholics decided it was fine to be Catholic on their own terms in other words, the Protestant notion of the supremacy of individual conscience triumphed and the authority structure of the Church was shattered and lost its credibility. And Greeley, the sociologist, has lots of statistics about the rejection of Church teachings by priests and laity to back up his claim. Hence, Greeley sees Vatican II as a revolutionary event that changed everything. Furthermore, says Greeley, to think or even pretend that this situation can be undone is folly the way in which Vatican II has been interpreted is irrevocable.
You have two options:
- Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
- Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.
If you're already a subscriber log-in here.