THE COST OF ECCLESIAL EQUALITY
Altar Boys: The Problem or the Solution?

November 2011By Ken Skuba

Ken Skuba is Grand Knight of a chivalrous boys’ organization called Order of Knights of the Most Precious Blood, Inc., whose members include altar boys in northeast Pennsylvania. He and his wife, Susan, and their five children live in Sugarloaf, Pennsylvania.

In August 2010 some fifty thousand altar servers descended upon Rome for the International Pilgrimage of Altar Servers with Pope Benedict XVI. It was the tenth such gathering of “ministrants” who serve the Novus Ordo Missae, and it marked the first time that altar girls outnumbered altar boys at the event. Writing in L’Os­servatore Romano, Lucetta Scaraffia hailed the news as the correction of a “profound inequality,” marking the end of “any attribution of impurity” to females. Correction? Attribution of impurity? Sounds like something was drastically wrong with the long-standing tradition of boys serving at the altar. “Correction” implies that there was a “problem,” but was the centuries-old practice of altar boys a problem in the Church?

Regrettably, other than the article in L’Osservatore Romano, there was little written about the event to stir new debate regarding the prevalence of altar girls. The dust has seemingly settled on this issue. For nearly twenty years — since the promulgation of Acta Apostolicae Sedis, a Vatican interpretation of canon 230.2 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law — girls have poured into church sanctuaries like a wall of water rushing downstream from a broken dam. Just as quickly, boys have moved out of the way. If we agree with Scaraffia, then justice has finally been served, and we are finally at equilibrium. If the pendulum has swung a little the other way, well, it was necessary to correct a serious “problem.”

In reality, by trying to solve a problem, the Church contributed to a bigger one. By introducing girls into our sanctuaries, the Church opened the dam, allowing that wall of water to uproot the organic process that, for centuries, has cultivated vocations to the priesthood. The numbers reported last August should have sounded the alarm for bishops and priests who have the authority to employ only boys. Will we have to wait twenty more years before the dam is plugged? By then, the ratio of altar girls to boys might be nine to one, and going to Mass on Sundays will be, for many, a day trip across the diocese to a centrally located parish because of the priest shortage.

Of course, it’s not fair to lay blame for the priest shortage on the alb-covered shoulders of altar girls, who, by and large, do an excellent job serving. Certainly, they are equal to the task and perform at least as well as, if not better than, their male counterparts. So, then, why should there be any issue with altar girls? For starters, it’s not about performance. Traditionally, priests have come from the ranks of the altar-server corps, and the introduction of female servers would soon discourage and drive away boys called to the priesthood. Indeed, the Vatican has acknowledged the great contribution of altar boys to the priesthood and, at the same time, cautioned that female altar servers could have an adverse effect. In a March 15, 1994, circular letter to the heads of episcopal conferences about the pending promulgation of Acta, Antonio Maria Cardinal Javierre Ortas, then-prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments (CDW), wrote:
The Holy See respects the decision [to use altar girls] adopted by certain Bishops for specific local reasons on the basis of the provisions of Canon 230.2. At the same time, however, the Holy See wishes to recall that it will always be very appropriate to follow the noble tradition of having boys serve at the altar. As is well known, this has led to a reassuring development of priestly vocations. Thus the obligation to support such groups of altar boys will always continue.
More recently, in a 2001 letter from the CDW in response to a bishop’s question about the use of altar girls, Jorge Cardinal Medina Estévez, current prefect of the CDW, reaffirmed that while female altar servers are permissible, altar boys are preferable and priests have the right to employ boys exclusively: “The Holy See [in giving] such an authorization may not, in any way, exclude men or, in particular, boys from service at the altar, nor require that priests of the diocese would make use of female altar servers, since ‘it will always be very appropriate to follow the noble tradition of having boys serve at the altar.’”


You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.



Back to November 2011 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
In the US and in many (most? all?) countries women live longer than men, men are much more likely to be alcoholics or addicts, and men are much more likely to be incarcerated (in the county in which I live 12-15% of the inmates in the county jail are women. I asked a group of men if those differences are rooted in biology or in society. A Jesuit, an administrator in a Catholic college as well as a professor of philosophy, said, "Both." That was his way of saying he didn't like the question. We are not Gnostics who believe that a pure spirit inhabits a male or female body. As Catholics we believe that the body and soul are united, and there are profound differences between women and men. Posted by: macroom2
November 08, 2011 10:10 AM EST
Why not cure the problem once and for all, by simply taking children from the service on the alter? We have adults as Eucharistic ministers and readers and while it may seem "cute" and "pretty" to have little Johnny and Mary on the later all dressed up, the fact is they are often not there mentally or spiritually. Most of the kids I serve with are in another world and have to be prompted to do their jobs. The simple solution is to take them out of the picture and put them in CCE classes or in the pews with mom and dad. Posted by: deaconsteveg
December 28, 2011 11:08 AM EST
With such a shortage of priests we now have many who are from other countries who's residence in this country is at the pleasure of the Bishop. I have been told by such a priest that he dare not do anything to stir things up with the Bishop. As for Deacon Steve, I for one am also not for permanent deacons! You may be excused to go sit in the pew. Posted by: silkie@frontiernet.net
October 30, 2014 12:13 AM EDT
Add a comment