Are We All 'Children of God'?

November 2008By F. Douglas Kneibert

F. Douglas Kneibert is a retired newspaper editor and a 1999 convert from Protestantism. He writes from Sedalia, Missouri.

In a concert in Rome this past September, pop singer Madonna, whose performances the Vatican has condemned for their blasphemous and even satanic content, dedicated her hit song "Like a Virgin" to Pope Benedict XVI. "I dedicate this song to the pope," the so-called Queen of Pop told the crowd of 60,000 adoring fans, "because I'm a child of God. All of you are also children of God."

Madonna's utterance, no doubt intended as provocation, is but one of a seemingly endless number of examples of the bandying about of this phrase in our culture. The notion that "we are all children of God" is not only a staple of liberal Christianity, it has been known to pop up in the homilies of otherwise orthodox clerics, in the musings of theologians, and in articles and books from both New Age and mainstream publishers. It rolls trippingly off the tongue in any number of venues.

The belief that we are all God's children simply by virtue of being born sounds wonderful. It has the great virtue of letting us off the hook for our erroneous beliefs and actions -- what loving Father would send His own children to Hell (if indeed there even is a Hell)? He has ceased to be a God of covenant who requires certain things of us, and is reduced to a sugar daddy who hands out His gifts free of charge, come one, come all.

The saying has been in circulation for so long that by now the average Catholic probably thinks it must be Church dogma. But simply saying it doesn't make it so. An examination of sacred Scripture and Church teaching shows what truly constitutes sonship with God.

You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.

Back to November 2008 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
"To pronounce everyone to be a child of God without any obligation on their part denies the unique salvific work of Jesus, declares faith to be unnecessary, and counts His atoning death as being of no value." Very logical reasoning. Outstanding article! Posted by: luvgabe
November 09, 2008 07:37 PM EST
Add a comment