Is Providence College All It's Cracked Up to Be?

October 2004By Jeffrey R. Jackson

Jeffrey R. Jackson is a 2003 graduate of Rhode Island College with a B.A. in Political Science.

Providence College, nestled in a gritty area of Providence, Rhode Island, is distinct among the nation's two hundred plus colleges and universities that are identified as Catholic. Its primary significance since its inauguration in 1917 is that it is the only college or university in all of North America that is owned and operated by the Order of Preachers Friars (i.e., the Dominican Fathers). The Dominicans, a bastion of scholarship dating back to the Order's founding in the 13th century, are the one religious community able to singularly claim as their own, St. Thomas Aquinas -- widely heralded as the patriarch of Catholic theological and philosophical scholarship, whose writings have undoubtedly served as the foundation, beacon, and compass for the intellectualization of Catholic orthodoxy throughout the centuries.

At Providence College (its colloquial title is PC), signs of the Dominican Order are found throughout the campus, including the newly erected St. Dominic Chapel, replete with stained-glass windows featuring the images of Dominican saints, situated across from a grotto adorned with a Blessed Virgin statue, and a dormitory aptly named Aquinas Hall. Despite the lack of any stunning architecture, the campus maintains a rather neat appearance (with the notable exception of many of the dormitories).

Further distinguishing the College is the vast clerical presence on its campus, lending the campus an even greater vintage appearance. The College claims to have the largest religious presence of all of the Catholic colleges on the East Coast, with a total of 57 Dominican Friars and Sisters as faculty and administrators. Add to this at least two diocesan clergy who hold full-time faculty posts. The Friar, donned in his traditional white habit with large rosary beads around the waist, is considered to be Providence College personified.

Much of the College's prominence has emerged by way of the positive acclamations of many a college guide: Beyond the standard U.S. News and World Report guide (by whom the College is ranked second in the northeast among regional institutions that concentrate on undergraduate studies), Providence College has received perhaps its most prestigious notoriety from the College Guide of the conservative National Review of some 10 years ago, which exalts the College's self-proclaimed emphasis on its Catholic, Dominican identity, and also on its traditional core curriculum that accentuates Western traditions. Known as "Development of Western Civilization," all students are required to complete a total of 20 credit hours of this standardized course during their first and second years. The College has also been acclaimed by neoconservative periodicals such as Crisis, First Things, and the National Catholic Register.

The conservative Intercollegiate Studies Institute (ISI), in collaboration with National Review, now produces Choosing the Right College: The Whole Truth About America's Top Schools (ISI College Guide for short), which examines famous American colleges such as Harvard, along with select other institutions of learning that function outside of the prevailing liberal "orthodoxies" and which are less "politicized." The ISI College Guide (2002 and 2004 editions) lauds Providence College for its "education for life" (rather than just for career), where Western tradition is "presented in its fullness" without the trendy trappings of multiculturalism and other pedagogical fads. However, the ISI College Guide perhaps unwittingly calls into question its claim as well as that of the College Administration by stating, "Providence would take its [Western Civ] curriculum up several notches if it simply assigned Homer's Iliad, say, rather than snippets of it culled from a textbook," which "would give reason for taking PC's academic claims more seriously."

You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.

Back to October 2004 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
As of August 2009, the Cardinal Newman Society has listed Providence College among its select list of faithful institutions of higher learning. I am pleased to say that this action was taken after the College's president of the past four years, Father Brian Shanley, banned the performance of the Vagina Monologues from the campus unequivocally. Also, the "sex professor," James Moorhead, has "retired" from his post. Father Shanley has also established a committee to address the "party school" atmosphere on the campus. While I don't agree with everything Father Shanley has done, he deserves kudos for taking the College back in an authentic, Dominican-Catholic direction. Congratulations, Providence College! Posted by: jjackson
October 04, 2009 08:46 PM EDT
Add a comment