The Legion of Christ & the Cult of Personality

September 2006By Renee Lockwood

Renee Lockwood (a pseudonym) is a writer from California.

I am a convert to the Catholic Faith from Protestantism. One of the things that I never liked about Protestantism was the way in which flocks of sheep would gather around a certain pastor or preacher as if he (or she) held the very reins of the Kingdom. The televangelist is the extreme example of this. Your typical American Protestant is a bit like a starving sheep adrift in the wild. These sheep bleat and wander around in order to find someone who seems to have some definite direction, and they gather around him, crowning him with all authority. Then the cult of personality evolves.

In the cult of personality, the spirit of the leader or founder will pervade the group at the deepest levels. There is only one personality who has a right to this level of influence in any organization: Christ. When any group gathers itself around a founder or personality other than Christ, there is bound to be trouble.

This brings me to the Legion of Christ. I have long been suspicious of the Legion as an organization (not necessarily individual Legionaries and Regnum Christi members), starting from the evening I was invited to a Regnum Christi outreach and was told that if I did not join, then perhaps I was "missing the invitation of Christ." This smacked so much of my experiences as a Protestant — red flags went up. One friend called the group "Dick and Jane Spirituality." I laughed, but since then I have thought more seriously about this comment. Why does this observation ring true? I believe it has to do with the cult of personality at its foundation.

You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.

Back to September 2006 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
Go to
Scroll down until you find the topic you need.
Start with Opus dei
Then Marianist movememt of priests
Then Legionaires for Christ.
Who is ecclesiastical masonry?
These topics and many mopre will tell you plenty. Sincerely Janice Tobergte
PS The story you wrote is true and then some.
Posted by: hopeandprayer
September 08, 2006 03:00 PM EDT
In the absence of consistent episcopal leadership, cults like the Legionaries of Christ will continue to spring up. The longer that bishops fail to teach the faith and avoid controversy at all costs, because they fear men instead of God, people will tend to gravitate to religious groups that proclaim a solid message even if it violates their Christian freedom. "Red flags" should automatically go up when the proponents of any religious organization take vows of silence that prohibit criticism of its practices and founder. Posted by: gwolak
September 10, 2006 07:47 PM EDT
Add a comment