LAST THINGS
Refugees From the Vernacular Mass

September 2005By Tom Bethell

Tom Bethell is a writer who lives in Washington, D.C.

I see there's a new book out, Why Men Hate Going to Church(Nelson Books). David Murrow, a television writer and producer, decided to write it after years of attending Catholic, Orthodox, mainline Protestant, and evangelical churches. He found that "no matter the name on the outside, there are always more women on the inside." I haven't read the book, but according to Peter Steinfels, who wrote a column about it for The New York Times, Murrow cites surveys showing that in most forms of church-related activity women constitute a great majority of participants, generally from 60 to 80 percent, and that most churches are "dominated by women and their values."

I read somewhere that Catholic Mass attendance in America tends to be about 60 or 65 percent female, and that corresponded to my own impression -- until my wife and I started going to the Tridentine Mass in Washington, D.C., earlier this year.

It is celebrated at 9 AM every Sunday at St. Mary Mother of God Church, on 5th Street NW. That's in downtown Washington, close to Chinatown and the new MCI Center (a sports arena). Ever since the indult was granted in 1990 by the Archbishop, the congregation has been growing. The pews are mostly full, and I would guess that there is an actual preponderance of men. There are plenty of young families with small children, and young women wearing chapel veils. They are not there for nostalgic reasons, obviously. They are too young to have grown up with the old Mass. Some come from the adjacent Diocese of Arlington, Virginia, where permission for the Tridentine rite has never been granted.

A friend of mine who lives in San Francisco and recently attended the Tridentine Mass across the Bay in Oakland tells me that she found very much the same thing in the congregation there -- lots of young families with many children, plenty of men, women wearing chapel veils, and the pews mostly full. The Oakland Tridentine Latin Mass is held at St. Margaret Mary Church every Sunday at 12:30 PM (a Novus Ordo Latin Mass is held every Sunday at 10:30 AM).


You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.



Back to September 2005 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
Mr. Bethell has hit the nail on the head with his point about men not wanting to attend the Novus Ordo - it's an abomonation. I live in a suburb of Pittsburgh and am fortunate that the Tridentine Mass is offered at St. Boniface in the the City. Though it's a 25 mile drive, I make an effort to attend several times a month. In a word, the experience is reverent. Something I strive to get out of the Novus Ordo but somehow it just doesn't compare. My hope is that at some point, more churches begin to offer at least one Latin Mass weekly. Posted by: tmw
June 06, 2006 09:22 PM EDT
I don't know if the Novus Ordo is "an abomination," but at best it's bland, vapid, and insipid. And then there's all that glad handing during the so called "kiss or peace"--I loathe that. We certainly need more reverence and masculinity.

There have been few hopeful signs here in the Diocese of Tulsa, though. Bishop Slattery said Mass on Christmas eve ad orientem.
Posted by: mlhearing
March 24, 2009 09:17 PM EDT
That should have read: "a few hopeful signs." Posted by: mlhearing
March 24, 2009 09:20 PM EDT
Add a comment