Five Common Misconceptions About Islam

May 2011By Andrew Bieszad

Andrew Bieszad has a master's degree in Islamic Studies and Christian-Muslim Relations from Hartford Seminary in Connecticut. He has conducted educational forums on Islam and Catholicism since 2007.

Muslims often claim that Islam is a misunderstood religion. This is partially true, insofar as many people do not understand the nature of Islam or what it teaches. Catholics are called to proclaim the Gospel to all people, including Muslims. However, it can be difficult to communicate Christ to a Muslim if one does not understand what the Muslim believes. The fact that Muslims have been aggressively proselytizing Catholics and other Christians has added to the confusion about Islamic theology. Let’s take a look at five common misconceptions about Islam among Catholics.

Misconception #1: The Bible & the Koran Are Basically the Same

Certain characters, stories, and sayings from the Bible can be found in the Koran, including the stories of Adam and Eve, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Isaac and Ishmael, and Jesus. The Koran also borrows passages from the Jewish Midrash, the Jewish Talmud, and heretical texts written primarily by Gnostics during the second and third centuries A.D., such as the Infancy Gospel of Thomas. The Koran draws upon all these sources equally, but presents them as though they were unique to the Koran. In fact, Mohammed’s earliest detractors pointed out that the “prophecies” he uttered and the stories he told were little more than his own retelling of “fables of the ancients” from Christian and Jewish texts.

More important than the Koran’s plagiarism of biblical stories, however, are the different ways Muslims and Catholics view their sacred texts. The Church teaches that the Bible is the word of God composed under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit. Dei Verbum, Vatican II’s “Dogmatic Constitution on Divine Revelation,” articulates this teaching thus:
Sacred Scripture is the speech of God as it is put down in writing under the breath of the Holy Spirit... In sacred Scripture, God speaks through men in human fashion.... Attention must be paid, inter alia, to “literary forms, for the fact is that truth is differently presented and expressed in the various types of historical writing, in prophetical and poetical texts,” and in other forms of literary expression. (nos. 9, 12)
Islam, on the other hand, teaches that the Koran is the literal word of Allah — the uncreated and eternal word of Allah. Islamic theology maintains that Mohammed was merely the vessel through which the Koran was transmitted to the world. This has been the unanimous consensus among mainstream Islamic theologians since the ninth century. The obvious problem with this theological position, which is often ignored by Muslim theologians, is that because the Koran is the uncreated and eternal word of Allah, it possesses the same eternal nature as Allah. This means that the Koran itself is divine and exists one in being with Allah. As much as Islam denounces the Holy Trinity in Christianity, it uses the same type of Trinitarian theology to explain the relationship between Allah, Mo­ham­med, and the Koran.

The final major difference between the Bible and the Koran can be found in their purposes. The Koran is self-defined as a “book of guidance sure to those who fear Allah” (2:2), which will lead Muslims along “the straight path” (1:6-7) toward obedience to Allah. In other words, the purpose of the Koran is to bring men to obedience; salvation is found in submission to the Koran’s teachings.

The Catholic faith, on the other hand, emphasizes that salvation is not found in absolute submission to a book’s teachings, but in a loving relationship with God Himself in Christ: “For God so loved the world, that he gave His only Son, so that he who believes in Him might not perish, but have eternal life” (Jn. 3:16).

You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.

Back to May 2011 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
We need a topical dossier about Islam to assist in reference. Very informative article. Thank you. Other articles in the current issue, which I find exceptionally educational, deserve to get into the dossier library. Posted by: joreill
May 18, 2011 11:31 AM EDT
Bieszad should write a book based upon this article to go along with the work of Brigitte Gabriel, Robert Spencer and others. He shows, clearly, that islam is inimicable with Christianity, and that the Koran is plaigerised from many sourcees, including the gnostic writings.

If the Koran was corrupted by the satanic verses in the 53rd Sura, isn't it posssible that the whole origen of the book is satanic? And that the appearance of the angel Gabriel to Mohammed was simply another impersonation by Satan?
Posted by: lyricmac
May 13, 2011 02:32 PM EDT
On reflection a separate dossier about Islam may not be a good idea considering the violent reaction it might provoke. In doing a search I found several articles in this site on this subject. Their system seems to be based mostly on fear. Often when you attempt to suppress the truth it speaks louder. Posted by: joreill
May 18, 2011 12:35 PM EDT
I found the site by chance doing an internet search on Islam and Christianity. Anita Crane has written 3 good interviews, and gave a good overview on Islam's problems. I found the 5 point summary very good, and hope I have the chance to use it with a Facebook friend who comes from Bangladash.
Posted by: domtoni
September 05, 2013 10:05 AM EDT
Add a comment