Fr. Fessio's Next Educational Disaster?

March 2005By Andrew Messaros

Andrew Messaros is a former professor of biology at Ave Maria College in Ypsilanti, Michigan, and currently a professor of neuroscience at The Medical College of Ohio in Toledo. (This is the NOR's fifth and final installment on Thomas Monaghan and his Ave Maria institutions.)

A tag-team developed in response to my NOR articles (Sept. 2004 and Nov. 2004) on the problematic administration of Ave Maria College (AMC) in Ypsilanti, Michigan, and Ave Maria University (AMU) in Naples, Florida.

My September piece challenged billionaire Thomas Monaghan on his self-orchestrated conflict-of-interest relationship as principal "donor" and Board Chairman for AMC Michigan. Monaghan did not reply. Instead, he apparently decided to send the President of AMU Florida, Nicholas Healy, who responded by reviewing the short and undistinguished history of AMU (NOR, Oct. 2004). I corrected Healy and brought the focus back on the Michigan College by documenting how AMC Board decisions made solely to benefit Florida came at the expense of long-lasting harm to students and employees in Michigan, including my own career and family (Nov.). Healy did not reply. Instead, he apparently decided to send Fr. Joseph Fessio, the Chancellor-turned-Provost of AMU Florida, who responded with an insolent characterization of me as whining, petty, sloppy, careless, double-minded, reckless, willfully dishonest, intellectually dishonest, and a poor scientist to boot (Jan. 2005). Did I mention dishonest?

Being the embodiment of so many repulsive characteristics in Fessio's mind, I think it is safe to conclude that my progeny will never be offered scholarships to attend AMU Florida. That's fine; I wouldn't risk having them go there anyway. No amount of institutionalized orthodoxy, external piety, or Vatican choir visits could convince me to entrust the education of my children to administrators such as Fessio who so cavalierly dismiss the legitimate and significant concerns of employees, parents, and students as "petty criticism," while bulldozing his way toward some "educational mission." At the administrative plate, Fr. Fessio's batting average is so far zero for two in keeping highly promising orthodox Catholic colleges open (Campion College is already defunct and AMC will soon be). Will AMU be next, making him zero for three?

The January 2005 NOR article is typical Fessio -- brash and unapologetic. If I were a mere passerby to the Ave Maria story, I'd probably think, "You da man, Fessio! Go get 'em!" The Rosanne Barr persona that he seems to relish does have a certain value -- at least to impressionable students, and adults and donors who don't work with him. But there are times when the Battler Priest image becomes immature and self-defeating -- when it is directed at fellow orthodox Catholics who are equally committed to the renewal of Catholic higher education as he is, but question the tactics used by a handful of administrators in achieving that goal. Fr. Fessio chose not to use his pastoral vocation to initiate, much less mediate, a charitable resolution to this baleful imbroglio. Instead, he chose to play the role of insult comic.

Fr. Fessio's "bring it on" public image appears to be merely that, a signature image, if now somewhat tattered, to dazzle the public. In reality, he has gone to great lengths to suppress facts surrounding the mismanagement of Ave Maria enterprises.

You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.

Back to March 2005 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
What it the No. 1 destination state for Michigan emigrants according to the Mackinac analysis? Florida.

The Mackinac analysis suggested Florida’s weather might be a factor — along with its “economic opportunities.”
No state taxes!

What smart business man wouldn't make a move like this?

So, the last resident better turn out the lights.
Posted by: jreeves56
March 28, 2007 06:11 AM EDT
it would be nice to hear some constructive comments regarding ave maria. maybe even some positive comments about this apostolate under siege. doesn't anyone out there think that the driving forces behind this apostolate are trying to do something good? or has the smoke of satan clouded everyone's eyes? Posted by: gespin3549
March 28, 2007 06:15 AM EDT
gespin3549 seems to think that any apostolate that is "trying to do something good" is worthy of support. But, as Messaros points out, you don't "do bad" on the way to "doing good." Even Fr. Fessio became a victim of Tom Monaghan's erratic Trump-style dictatorship when, a few days ago, Monaghan told Fessio to "clear out his desk" and "leave campus immediately." Does orthodox Catholicism in the United States really need a Citizen Cane? Having a billion dollars doesn't guarantee one can make sound decisions. A billion dollars does, however, tend to corrupt the mind.

And what utter arrogance for Monaghan and Fessio to pretend Ave Maria is offering something unique in Catholic education. One need only look to Thomas Aquinas College and Christendom (for starters) to find sound academic institutions run by qualified orthodox Catholic academics with a proven track record. Even pockets at Notre Dame and Georgetown (seriously) are havens for the orthodox Catholic student.
Posted by: charing cross
March 28, 2007 10:24 AM EDT
charing cross - pockets at ND and Georgetown? Give me a break. BTW every article I read about AVE Maria seems to be about those in MI griping about the move to Fl. He who has the gold rules - that's the real world. Beyond that, shouldn't all of us be focused on helping all orthodox catholic collegs to succeed and put pressure on those who call themselves Catholic to return to church teaching or fess up that they are no longer Catholic? Posted by: wunsch
March 28, 2007 10:42 PM EDT
Add a comment