Skinheads & Rock Stars -- or Saints?

March 2000By Eric J. Scheske

Eric J. Scheske writes from Sturgis, Michigan. His articles have appeared in Gilbert!, Touchstone, and The Catholic Faith.

Almost every man ... will be found to have ... some hero or other, living or dead, ... whose character he endeavours to assume, and whose performances he labours to equal. When the original is well-chosen and judiciously copied, the imitator arrives at excellences which he could never have attained without direction .... -- Samuel Johnson

In the 19th century Thomas Carlyle published Heroes and Hero-Worship, in which he taught that hero-worship is natural to humans: When a man is your superior, you act naturally by looking up to him and following him. Though Carlyle's theory has distinct limitations, there is much truth in his basic insight. All men naturally seek heroes. It seems to me that this impulse arises from our primordially incomplete existence due to Original Sin. We intuitively sense our incompleteness, which results in an innate anxiety. We seek to complete ourselves -- to assuage our anxiety -- in various ways. We, for instance, seek knowledge from an innate sense that knowledge makes us more complete (which is why Aristotle began his Metaphysics with the words, "All men by nature desire to know").

We also seek to complete ourselves through other people. This is not surprising because we are social beings -- creatures made to be with one another and therefore beings with an instinctive attraction to one another. Our attempt to complete ourselves through other people frequently takes the form of seeking someone better, a person whose life and example give us a clue about the answers to life's questions. When we find such a person, we have found a hero.

Hero-worship is so ingrained in our natures that if we cannot find a hero we may follow a pseudo-hero. A recent story in U.S. News & World Report about homelessness noted the growing number of homeless youth. According to the story, there are increasing numbers of radically disaffected teenagers and young adults (complete with tattoos and body-piercings -- one youth had a third eye tattooed on his forehead) who deliberately choose to live on the street. They confidently say they are engaging in the "Not-Wanting-To-Do-Anything" rebellion. But even they, slack as they may be, have heroes. Many have made their way to the Berkeley and San Francisco area, seeing themselves as descendants of the Haight-Ashbury street movement of the 1960s. Professing to admire nothing, still they imitate the hippies of the Sixties who disdained the conventionalities of everyday society.

You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.

Back to March 2000 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
Great Article. I notice the drawing looks suspiciously of John Corapi who is a great example of the problem. The saints are our best examples for it is only they who we are assurred have reached Heaven. But many search for heroes in today's society-those who know the present-day problems Faithful Catholics face on a daily basis. I am of the opinion that some heroes are heroes as long as we realize that they are not God, they are human and do, and WILL let us down. We must be aware of this and determine wether this is a human failing to be forgiven, or a diabolical one to avoid. I believe Fr. Eutenauer to be the former, and Mr. Corapi the latter. Always keep in mind that men and women of God fall all the time and they will let us down. We are all sinners. Posted by: Tess208
February 04, 2013 10:52 AM EST
Add a comment