The Language of the Body & the Mass
February 1999By W. Patrick Cunningham
W. Patrick Cunningham is a journalist in San Antonio, Texas.
The rhythms of our worship become part of us; sacred actions long practiced become second nature. Catholics at Mass sit to hear the homily and rise together to recite the Creed and to pray the General Intercessions. They sit again while the collection basket goes round and while the priest blesses the gifts of bread and wine. Then, to the priests exhortation Pray that our sacrifice may be acceptable they reply May the Lord accept the sacrifice at your hands, and all rise together for the prayers that culminate in the communal recitation or singing of the Sanctus, which ends with Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord, Hosanna in the highest!
And then and then what happens? According to the rubrics published by the American bishops, according to immemorial custom, according to the instructions in the missalette in the pew, we kneel. But this Sunday you are not at your home parish, and as your knees begin to bend, you hesitate, noticing that many people are still standing. Have you mistaken the moment, rapt as you are in a mystic reverie or daydreaming? Isnt this the Eucharistic Prayer and Consecration? Dont we kneel now? You kneel uncertainly, distracted by an uneasy need to survey your fellow worshipers: Almost all of them are standing. If you continue kneeling, your view of the altar will be blocked and you risk sidelong glances from those towering over you. You surreptitiously check the missalette: Yes, it says Kneel.
Whats going on?
Up, Up and We Pray
The liturgical norm in the U.S., according to custom and clear directives from the bishops, is that the congregation at Mass should kneel between the Sanctus and the Lords Prayer, that is, during the entire Eucharistic Prayer. But some liturgists have been arguing that this is incorrect, that Catholics Should Stand at the Consecration (as D. Phillipart wrote in U.S. Catholic in July 1993). Kneeling, he said, is a penitential posture, and is like mourning on Easter . Erasto Fernandez, writing in Emmanuel (100:293), opines that the standing posture is the expression of the holy freedom of the children of God acquired at Baptism. Fernandez states, citing Deuteronomy 18:3-5, that for community or liturgical prayer, the common posture is standing, sometimes with the arms extended. He allows that it is customary to kneel during the recitation of the institution narrative [the Consecration] out of deep respect for the central action. But he insists that one could also remain standing. Phillipart would restrict kneeling to penitential times, private prayer, and extraliturgical devotions. If Christ is present in all the Mass, why kneel at the Consecration?
You have two options:
- Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
- Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.
If you're already a subscriber log-in here.