A Church Rises from the Ruins

January-February 2015By Thomas Basil

Thomas Basil, who resides in the Archdiocese of Baltimore, is a 1996 convert to the Catholic Church. His trip to Estonia took place in September 2013. Seven earlier articles on his travels in Europe have appeared in the NOR.

Tallinn, the capital of Estonia, looks like a movie set created by Walt Disney. Along its medieval walls are fortress towers and arched gates. Within is a maze of narrow lanes and ancient buildings. Its town hall, the oldest still standing in Europe, dates to 1404. A dozen church spires pierce the skyline. Here and there restored crucifixes and images of haloed saints peer down from old walls. On the steps of Tallinn’s lone Catholic parish, I asked a young Estonian man why he came to Mass. “I’m a convert,” he said. “I started reading philosophy. It all pointed to God. Why did I become a Catholic? Because it is the truth.” He concluded wistfully, “But there are not many Catholics around here, at least for the past five hundred years.”

Timing is everything. Nine hundred years earlier, my acquaintance would have witnessed the Viking lifestyle and the god Tharapita prevailing in this Baltic area. Those Estonians terrorized Christianized Swedes and Danes with coastal raiding parties. The evangelization of Estonia began in earnest in 1193 when Pope Celestine III called for a crusade against Europe’s last pagan holdouts. Celestine’s first episcopal appointee was speared by hostile Balts. The next, Bishop Albert von Buxthoeven, firmly established a bishopric in Riga (Latvia) by 1201, helped by an army of fifteen hundred Germans.

The following year, Bishop Albert founded a new crusading order known as the Livonian Brothers of the Sword. In 1208 the order’s knights turned against the tribes of modern-day Estonia, launching a war that lasted off and on for two decades. Pope Innocent III assisted by dedicating the land to the Blessed Virgin Mary in 1215. Conquered tribes accepted Catholicism under the terms of surrender. Naturally, some took to the faith better than others: The inhabitants of the island of Saaremaa, for example, twice renounced Christ and massacred the island’s Catholic priests and resident Germans. But evidence suggests that Catholicism became normative from about 1227 on. Medieval Estonia became home to at least a hundred churches and a dozen monasteries and convents.

Alas, Martin Luther’s revolution smashed all this. Estonia fell under Swedish rule in 1561. Tolerant Sweden was far in the future — Catholicism was a forbidden faith in the sixteenth century. Sweden forcibly expelled Estonia’s last adherents to the old faith in 1626. For almost a hundred and fifty years, no record exists of any Catholic presence. But in 1770 Estonia was swallowed up by the Russian Empire. The czar granted religious freedom to ethnic minorities, and German and Polish migrants re-established Estonian Catholicism. Except that it was not truly Estonian. In the words of historian Msgr. Vello Salo, “For the Estonians, it remained a church of foreigners” (The Catholic Historical Review, April 2002).

You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.

Back to January-February 2015 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
One hopes that this rise will continue but what does it constitute and what does it mean? The Catholic population of Estonia today is small, some put it at approximating 6,000. More importantly it is unclear who these "new" Catholics are, and what percentage of the 6000 do they constitute. More importantly do the new Catholics adhere to traditional Catholicism or are they much like the rest of European Catholics who have succumbed to secularism and follow their religion cafeteria style? Catholics in name only, who believe in what they want to believe, not what Holy Mother Church tells them they should believe.

When the population of traditional Catholics begins to rise in large numbers again, then it will be time to truly cheer.
Posted by: dagbat1
January 21, 2015 04:52 PM EST
Add a comment