EVANGELICAL, EPISCOPALIAN, CATHOLIC
The Rhone to the Thames to the Tiber

January-February 2011By Taylor Marshall

Taylor Marshall, currently a Ph.D. candidate in philosophy at the University of Dallas, is the author of The Crucified Rabbi: Judaism and the Origins of Catholic Christianity (St. John Press, 2009) and The Catholic Perspective on Paul: The Apostolic Origins of Catholic Christianity (St. John Press, 2010). This article originally appeared in the September 2010 issue of The Coming Home Network International Newsletter and is reprinted with permission. © 2010 Coming Home Network, PO Box 8290, Zanesville OH 43702; www.chnetwork.org.

When I was eight years old my best friend informed me that I was going to Hell since I had not been baptized. He had been raised in a devout Missouri Synod Lutheran home and knew well enough that he belonged to Christ through baptism. I, on the other hand, had not been raised in any Christian tradition, nor had I been baptized. It seemed, then, that I would not be saved, nor could I be saved. Baptism remained for me something mysterious and unattainable.

My family was not Christian but was generally virtuous. My mother forbade certain shows and movies as inappropriate for little ones. Lying and stealing were condemned and traditional values upheld. Nevertheless, religion was lacking. My maternal grandfather abandoned his childhood Lutheran faith when the pastor publicly rebuked him regarding his tithe. My maternal grandmother left her childhood Catholic faith when she witnessed a priest scold a pregnant friend who turned to the Church for help after she had conceived out of wedlock. My paternal grandfather died while my father was a boy and, as a result, my father did not receive any religious education. Both my parents were spiritual orphans and, as my Lutheran friend observed, I had not been baptized and was heading toward eternal damnation.

Salvation Through Scripture

All this changed when I was twelve. I received a baseball autographed by the catcher of the Texas Rangers, Darryl Porter. Under his name he had written: “Rom 10:9.” I was eager to decipher his secret message for me, and I soon found out that this code word was a Bible verse. When I finally got hold of a Bible and found Romans chapter 10, verse 9, my heart filled with joy as I read these words: “If you confess with your mouth, ‘Jesus is Lord,’ and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved.”

At last, I thought, I’ve discovered a way to be saved!

Immediately I said aloud, “Jesus is Lord” (since the Scriptures instructed “with your mouth”). I uttered my first prayer to God, confessing that God raised Jesus Christ from the dead. I didn’t know what these words meant, but I knew that I wanted to be saved and that I’d discovered a way of salvation without the apparent prerequisite of baptism.

I was eager to learn more about Christianity, so I began to ask questions. I wanted to know about Baptists, Lutherans, Methodists, and Catholics. I discovered the meaning behind holidays like Christmas and Easter. Before long our whole family was attending services together at the nearby church, a Methodist congregation. During this time I felt that God was calling me to become a pastor.

One day a well-meaning evangelical Protestant camp counselor told me that I must read the Holy Scriptures every day because the Antichrist would soon arrive and confiscate every copy of the Holy Bible remaining on earth! In the days of tribulation, he explained, the only Scriptures we would possess would be those we hid in our hearts through memorization. As a 16-year-old looking for spiritual direction, I took his admonition seriously. In the next two years, I read the entire Bible from Genesis to Revelation three times consecutively.

In time I discovered that there were “liberal” and “conservative” churches. As it was explained to me, “liberal” churches follow reason, and “conservative” churches follow Scripture. I certainly wanted to be one of the faithful Christians who followed Scripture.

I visited a charismatic congregation and was impressed by the “altar calls.” At the end of every sermon the pastor would ask all present to close their eyes and bow their heads. He next addressed those who were not Christians or who needed to recommit their lives to Christ. Then he would call them forward. These penitents often cried while the music roared. I found this all very impressive. But after about three months, I noticed that the same people “got saved” week after week. The routine increasingly appeared formulaic. I desired something deeper.


You have two options:

  1. Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
  2. Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.

If you're already a subscriber log-in here.



Back to January-February 2011 Issue

Read our posting policy Add a comment
My spiritual journey is different in many ways, but the discovery of the Catholic teaching of the the Blessed Virgin is very much the same. I have been trained in the Anglo-Catholic tradition of the Oxford Movement and always felt a strong pull to Catholicism. The author's description of his meeting with Cardinal Baum and the Cardinal's words, "...you are a Catholic, it is time to come home.", hit my heart with a joy I find hard to describe. Thank you. Posted by: frtrue@newwavecomm.net
January 26, 2011 11:08 AM EST
Thank you for sharing the story of your journey home. Please pray for my children, who were born and raised Catholic, but due to poor catechesis and the secular environment do not appreciate the great gift they were given. Posted by: golfer21
February 09, 2011 03:42 PM EST
Add a comment